US EPA vows to find regulatory fix by year-end after biodiesel fraud
Washington (Platts)--15Aug2012/416 pm EDT/2016 GMT
The US Environmental Protection Agency expects to propose a regulatory
fix by the end of the year aimed at restoring the market for renewable fuel
credits after three fraud cases shut out all but the largest biodiesel
Gina McCarthy, assistant administrator for EPA's Office of Air and
Radiation, told a Democrat in the House of Representatives on Tuesday that
the agency hoped to have the solution in place by early 2013.
The proposal would contain elements pushed by the oil industry, notably
an "affirmative defense" policy that would afford refiners some protection
when they discover invalid or fraudulent renewable identification numbers
(RINs) on their books despite their best efforts to verify them beforehand.
Article continues below...
Biofuels in one place. All Day. Every day.
Platts isn't new to providing biofuels information and reporting, but biofuels have grown so much that it deserves its own home. Introducing Platts' biofuels-dedicated solutions: Platts Biofuels Alert real-time service, Market Data - Biofuels and Biofuelscan daily global newsletter.
"This best effort would be demonstrated by purchasing RINs that have
been validated through an independent third-party auditor executing an
EPA-approved Quality Assurance Program," McCarthy wrote to Representative
Gene Green of Texas. "The affirmative defense would ensure that refiners and
other program participants who meet the conditions of the affirmative defense
will not face civil penalties."
EPA has declared invalid 140 million RINs representing about 930,000
gallons of biodiesel. Oil companies use the credits to demonstrate compliance
with the Renewable Fuel Standard, which requires them to blend a certain
amount of ethanol, biodiesel and advanced biofuels into US motor fuel
supplies every year.
"We understand that many in industry are seeking a resolution to these
market uncertainties before making purchasing decisions for RINs in the new
year," McCarthy wrote. "To that end, on an expedited basis, the EPA expects
to issue a proposal before the end of 2012, with a final action as soon as
possible in 2013."
McCarthy said any new elements of the program, including third-party
auditors, would be voluntary.
"Early indications from the industry are that obligated parties prefer
the option of buying validated RINs from small producers and keeping the
existing program for RINs purchased from the largest, most well-established
producers," she wrote.
For months, EPA has been talking with refiners, the National Biodiesel
Board and other industry players about regulatory changes that might return
liquidity to the biodiesel RINs market.
Since the first fraud case became public last autumn, refiners have opted
to buy credits from biofuel giants that have balance sheets big enough to
refund any invalid RINs.
Stephen Brown, vice president of government affairs for refiner Tesoro,
said that trend continues more than a year later.
"Frankly, because there's no other alternative, we can only buy from
biodiesel producers [for which] we have some degree of certainty that their
RINs are valid, that their feedstocks are legitimate, that in the event that
their RINs turn out not to be valid, we can get replacement RINs that will be
valid," Brown said.
"That really falls to the largest of the biodiesel producers," he added.
"So this delay in getting some kind of rule across the finish line is
unfortunately putting a real and substantial financial squeeze on the
independent biodiesel producers -- the vast majority of which I'm sure are
completely honest and aboveboard."
The bogus credits identified by EPA were sold by Clean Green Fuel of
Perry Hall, Maryland, Absolute Fuels of Lubbock, Texas, and Green Diesel of
A federal jury in Baltimore convicted Rodney Hailey, owner of Clean
Green Fuel, in June of fraud, money laundering and violating the Clean Air
Act by selling $9.1 million in credits without producing a drop of biodiesel.
A grand jury in Texas last week indicted Absolute Fuels owner Jeffrey
Gunselman on similar fraud charges, accusing him of selling $42 million in
No charges have been filed against Green Diesel or CEO Philip Rivkin.
The fraud cases continue to rattle the markets for biodiesel and RINs,
as traders suspect more fake credits could be circulating. A House committee
investigating the issue said in May that the 140 million invalid RINs might
double as more cases emerge.
--Meghan Gordon, firstname.lastname@example.org
--Edited by Lisa Miller, email@example.com