Chevron may rethink Ecuador strategy after US court move on Shell: analyst
New York (Platts)--18Oct2011/535 pm EDT/2135 GMT
Chevron likely wants a resolution in the ongoing legal dispute over the
former Texaco assets in Ecuador, Oppenheimer analyst Fadel Gheit said
Tuesday, adding that Monday's US Supreme Court agreeing to hear a case
charging Shell for human rights violations in Nigeria could hold implications
"The legal team at Chevron will rethink their position" after the
Supreme Court said it would hear the Shell case, Gheit said in a phone
"If you open the case for Shell, you have to open it for Ecuador," Gheit
said. Gheit wants Chevron to reach a settlement in the Ecuador case because
the dispute has become a "distraction" to the company.
The Supreme Court agreed to decide whether Shell can be held liable for
acts of torture and other human rights violations in Nigeria in the 1990s.
The court agreed to hear an appeal of a case brought by 12 Nigerian
plaintiffs who allege Shell should be held responsible for violence against
people who opposed oil exploration in the Ogoni region of the Niger Delta.
Article continues below...
Sign up for Oilgram News
Oilgram News brings fast-breaking global petroleum and gas news to your desktop every day. Our extensive global network of correspondents report on supply and demand trends, corporate news, government actions, exploration, technology, and much more.
Analyst Mark Gilman of Benchmark Capital said in a phone interview that
the jurisdictional aspect in the Shell case shares a "common denominator in a
very limited way" with the Chevron dispute in Ecuador. But the Nigeria case
is "very different" because Shell has assets in Nigeria while Chevron no
longer owns Ecuador assets, Gilman said.
Chevron spokesman Kent Robertson said in an email that a link between the
two "isn't quite accurate."
"Chevron is being sued under Ecuadorian law, not US law," he said. "I'm
not sure I see how a ruling from the US Supreme Court, regardless of which
way it goes, would have any influence over Ecuador's courts."
In a note to investors on Tuesday, Gheit said "we think a $2-$3 billion
settlement, or 10% of the $27 billion judgment, could remove uncertainty and
reflect positively on the stock."
MET WITH WATSON
"The $20 billion is totally out of the question," Gheit said. But "10
cents on the dollar would probably be a good starting point."
Gheit, Gilman and other analysts met with Chevron CEO John Watson, CFO
Patricia Yarrington and others on Monday over lunch.
Gilman estimates that the Ecuador dispute puts a 3%-5% "discount" on
Chevron's stock price, but said: "we believe the shares are undervalued
significantly more than that." Benchmark has a "buy" rating on Chevron.
Of Chevron CEO Watson, Gheit said, "I really think that he wants to get
this thing over with." The years-long dispute is a "distraction" to the
company, Gheit said.
Chevron "would like to see this case closed," Gheit said. "In my view,
it will probably entail payment."
Unlike Gheit, Gilman does not think the litigation is "a material
distraction to the management." Debating whether Chevron might settle "is not
terribly worthwhile because I don't think it's going anywhere," he said.
"They're not going to settle this case. Therefore, it's moot."
Robertson said "Chevron takes no pleasure in litigation and has tried to
resolve this case in the past. "However... it is hard to see a way forward
without the government of Ecuador owning up to its remediation
Karen Hinton, a spokeswoman for the plaintiffs in the Lago Agrio case,
said in an email that, "we won an $18 billion judgment against Chevron for
massive contamination.... If and when the judgment is upheld by Ecuador's
appeals court, we will enforce the judgment."
Plaintiffs in Lago Agrio, Ecuador, have argued that Texaco, which
Chevron acquired in 2001, left behind a massive sprawl of oil pollution that
sickened residents in the area.
Chevron has said that it has remediated for the pollution and it also
has argued that a lawyer for the plaintiffs pressured members of the Ecuador
judicial system to make a ruling favorable to the plaintiffs.
Gheit Tuesday raised Oppenheimer's 12-18 month price target for Chevron
stock to $120 from $110. In intraday trading, the company's stock was up
1.66% at $100.25/share.
--Leslie Moore Mira, email@example.com